Cigar: The Horse Who Made the Earth Move
It was 30 years ago that Cigar won the NYRA Mile, the race that would bear his name since 1997 and won this past weekend by Locked. In all my years covering racing I have never been closer to any horse more than I was to Cigar, who took me to places I never could have dreamed of. So in honor of the 27th running of the Cigar Mile and on the 10th anniversary of his death in 2014 here is a travelogue of my adventures with the great Cigar. ~ Steve Haskin
Cigar: The Horse Who Made the Earth Move
By Steve Haskin
Cigar – 1995 Breeders’s Cup Classic champion and 2-time Horse of the Year
If the headline sounds familiar I have used those words on very rare and special occasions. It was Ernest Hemingway who wrote in For Whom the Bell Tolls, “But did thee feel the earth move?”
With Cigar I felt it on several occasions, as he took me on a whirlwind journey through three countries in 1996, from my first ever cross-country flight on the fastest private jet in the world to the then unchartered deserts of Dubai to his emotional final career race in Canada to a teary farewell at the National Horse Show at Madison Square Garden in the heart of New York City.
Cigar paved an indelible path that year going to places no horse had ever gone before, and each time he took me along for the ride of a lifetime. No horse had ever made his first start of the year less than 24 hours after he, his owner, breeder, trainer, and jockey swept the Eclipse Awards 3,000 miles away. No Horse of the Year, or any horse for that matter, had ventured into the unknown halfway across the world to compete in a new race that boasted the richest purse in history. He was the first Horse of the Year and Breeders’ Cup Classic winner to defend his title at Woodbine Race Course in Canada. And finally he was the first horse to be given a police escort from Belmont Park to Midtown Manhattan to bid farewell to racing at the famed Madison Square Garden.
So hop aboard and let’s go back to 1996 and the Gulliver-like travels of “America’s Horse.”
Jet setting
It was early that year at the Eclipse Awards dinner at the Hotel Del Coronado, just across San Diego Bay, that I really became close to Cigar. Not only was I assigned to cover the event, I also arranged to fly from San Diego to Fort Lauderdale that same night on Cigar’s owner/breeder Allen Paulson’s Gulfstream 4 jet, which at the time held the speed record for traveling around the world. The following day, Cigar was scheduled to make his 6-year-old debut in the Donn Handicap at Gulfstream Park for trainer Bill Mott and jockey Jerry Bailey. And I was assigned to cover that as well.
The other passengers on the plane were Allen and Madeleine Paulson, Madeleine’s beloved Jack Russell terrier Oliver, Bill and Tina Mott, Jerry and Suzee Bailey, and my DRF colleague, the legendary Joe Hirsch. My first thought was, if the plane went down I’d be a mere footnote at the bottom of the story.
Normally, Paulson would fly the plane himself, but because of the overnight flight, scheduled to arrive in Fort Lauderdale at about 5:30 a.m. and the big day ahead, he decided to hire a crew and go as a passenger. After boarding the plane, Paulson undid his suspenders, rolled up his sleeves, and took a seat in the front row. Soon after takeoff, Madeleine, reverting to her days as a flight attendant for Pan Am, took drink orders and put out plates of cakes and pastries and platters of food.
Mott and Bailey sat up front handicapping the Saturday card. Mott later turned to me and said in jest, “Well, what do you think, Steve? This is a tough assignment for you, but I guess somebody’s gotta do it.”
About 100 miles west of Tampa, the plane was scheduled to fly over Checkpoint Cigar, for which the horse was named. “Do you want to go up to the cockpit when we fly over it?” Madeleine asked me. “You can go up there anytime you want.”
After beginning to doze off, I looked up through half-closed eyes to see Madeleine covering me with a blanket, bless her heart.
When I awoke, the lights were off and everyone was asleep. Although Cigar would be a heavy favorite in the Donn, Mott was cautiously optimistic. Here he was going to Cigar’s debut and having to stare at the Horse of the Year Eclipse Award trophy that was sitting right in front of him. “I don’t like this scenario of getting all these Eclipse Awards, and everyone is happy, and then, all of a sudden it’s D-Day again in less than 24 hours,” he said earlier. “We’re setting ourselves up for a bunch of long faces.”
At 4:20 a.m., Paulson began to stir. He walked to the back of the plane and told me were getting close to Checkpoint Cigar, located west of Sarasota. I made my way to the cockpit, having to gingerly step over Oliver. The view of the Florida coastline was magnificent, as if we were in a simulator. Although the lights kept getting closer it seemed as if we weren’t moving. “Isn’t that beautiful?” the pilot asked. “It’s like a big video screen. We’re flying 80% the speed of sound, but this plane flies faster than this.”
The west coast of Florida quickly came and went and after flying over the darkness of the Everglades we descended on the lights of Eastern Florida. The landing was smooth as silk, and after the plane came to a stop, Paulson got up, put his suspenders back on, rolled down his sleeves, and said to Mott, “Ready to go to work, Bill?”
Several yards from the plane, Paulson’s limo was waiting to take us all to our respective hotels. As I stepped down from the plane, Paulson reminded me, “Well, you just flew in the fastest plane in the world.”
It was only appropriate, because later that day I’d be watching the fastest horse in the world. The same horse who had won all 10 of his starts in 1995 culminating with a victory in the Breeders’ Cup Classic at Belmont Park. Cigar won the Donn with ease and soon it would be time to explore new horizons and rewrite the history books.
A spectacle in the desert
It was Bill Mott’s assistant Tim Jones who accompanied Cigar to Dubai and supervised his early training for the inaugural Dubai World Cup. I was there providing lead coverage of the event for the Daily Racing Form. No one had any idea what to expect or what Dubai would be like. Would this race, with its record $4 million purse and horses representing Dubai, the United States, the United Kingdom, Japan, and Australia, catch on and become a permanent fixture or blow away in the desert sand? Many believed a lot would depend on how Cigar did and how the American horses handled the long trip.
Cigar, as usual was accompanied by his pony Snowball, whose snow white color made him almost as popular as Cigar. One day, a photo of Snowball appeared on the front page of a local newspaper with the caption identifying him as Cigar.
During the days leading up to the World Cup, I signed up for a day trip that included a one-hour drive out to the middle of the desert followed by a hair-raising and back-breaking mini-van ride up and down the sand dunes at breakneck speed. That was followed by a lunch in an “authentic Bedouin village,” a camel ride, and a falcon show. It was a box lunch in a tent in the middle of nowhere, the camel ride was more like a 5-year-old’s first pony ride that lasted less than a minute, but still fun, and when I enquired about the falcon show I was told, and I quote, “The falcon died on Tuesday.”
The Maktoums, headed by Sheikh Mohammed, put on quite a show that was unlike anything ever seen before, from the outrageous party in the desert to the raucous rock concert that was originally supposed to feature The Rolling Stones to the dazzling pre-race festivities. On race night, a salmon pink sunset, combined with the floodlights from Nad al Sheba Race Course, illuminated the ornate mosques off in the distance, making them sparkle in the twilight. To a Westerner, it was a scene right out of Disney’s Magic Kingdom.
But now it was time for the big race. What no one realized was that shortly before the World Cup word spread quickly throughout the media tent that Cigar was going to be scratched due to a foot problem. No one knew it was something they were dealing with since the horse arrived, but had it under control. Had I come all this way only to see Cigar scratched? Everyone waited for the official word, but it never came. It was only when the horses began walking to the paddock from the barn area and I looked through my binoculars and saw Cigar that the rumor was officially quashed.
Cigar, right with Jerry Bailey aboard, wins the inaugural Dubai World Cup over Soul of the Matter
I watched the race at the top of the small concrete grandstand with Ray Paulick, then the editor of the Blood-Horse. Cigar had the lead down that long stretch, but here came fellow American Soul of the Matter, trained by Dick Mandella, who pulled on even terms inside the final furlong and looked to be the stronger of the two. When Cigar dug deep and battled back nearing the wire to win by a half-length Ray and I jumped up and down like school kids and hugged each other, and then bulled our way through a sea of dishdashas (the traditional long white robes) down to the winner’s circle. Needless to say, that was another surreal moment provided by Cigar; one that no one had ever experienced before. Cigar had come to Dubai and conquered, thus assuring the success of the Dubai World Cup.
Back home
One of my fondest memories of Cigar was the day he arrived at Belmont Park following his historic victory in the inaugural Dubai World Cup. He hadn’t felt a cool breeze in his face in four months, having been in Florida and then Dubai. Now he was back home, walking up Secretariat Avenue, passing rows of trees and grassy paddocks, and hearing the occasional crowing of a rooster and the chirping of sparrows, as a brisk April wind ruffled his mane.
Judging from the way he pulled assistant trainer Simon Bray and groom Seth Gregory while returning to his old home, Barn 25, after 36 hours in quarantine, there was no doubt he was happy to be back in familiar surroundings.
Although he had lost a little weight and a bit of shine to his coat, it didn’t seem as if the long trip to Dubai, the hot, humid days in the desert, and his gut-wrenching victory in the Dubai World Cup took too much out of him.
Leaving the quarantine barn, Cigar continually gnawed away on his lip chain. The farther he walked the more on the muscle he became, bouncing along on his toes and trying to prop on occasion. This was the first blast of cool air to hit him in months and he was loving every minute of it. “Man, this horse is pumped; he’s really pulling on me,” Bray said.
As they turned down one of the horse paths, a van blocked the way and Bray and Gregory had to walk Cigar in circles until the van driver could be located. He finally emerged from a nearby barn, and as he got into his van, a truck pulled alongside. The driver of the truck opened the window and shouted to the van driver: “You gotta move that van for the mighty Ceeegar, the greatest horse of all time.”
When Cigar arrived at Mott’s barn, he was reluctant to go in his stall, balking several times. That was the last place he wanted to be, but finally he gave in. “There you go, buddy, back in stall 3,” Bray said to him as he removed his lip chain and gave him a friendly whack on the rear end.
Once free, Cigar let it all out, rolling several times in the straw, grunting and squealing. After getting up and pawing at the ground, he charged the webbing and thrust his head out the stall door, scattering whoever was standing nearby.
As Bray and Gregory returned to the quarantine barn to get Cigar’s pony, Snowball, who had gained fame himself while in Dubai, Cigar stood at his stall door with his head up and ears cocked, staring out the barn window and up and down the shed with that familiar white eye.
“You got your favorite window and your favorite stall back,” said day watchman Jimmy Camic. “I’m just glad he’s back safe, thank God. I’ll sit here with a two-by-four if I have to, and God forbid if any sonofabitch gives me a hard time.”
Soon, Gregory’s parents and brother arrived at the barn to take their son back to a hero’s welcome in their hometown of Garrattsville, New York, 16 miles from Cooperstown. Gregory had accompanied Cigar to Dubai when the horse’s regular groom, Juan Campuzano, was unable to get his visa processed in time.
“Seth, the guys at the pharmacy all said to send their congratulations,” Gregory’s mother told him. “I was in there yesterday. They were so excited they can’t wait to see you.”
“I don’t know why I’m such a hero,” Gregory said. “He did it all.”
But Cigar had a way of making heroes out of all those close to him.
Saying goodbye
It was Cigar’s final race, and the script called for him to go out a winner in the 1996 Breeders’ Cup Classic. He had compiled a historic 16-race winning streak before it ended in Del Mar’s Pacific Classic. The Breeders’ Cup was his swan song, but a nose and a head separated him from the storybook ending. The sun had just begun to descend behind Woodbine’s clubhouse turn as Cigar walked off the track for the last time. Shafts of light beamed down on him from an amber sky, creating a setting that was meant for a triumphant farewell. But Cigar’s weary legs and cracked feet, that had carried him some 25,000 miles across the United Stakes and to Dubai, could not carry him those final few inches.
In his final start, Cigar finishes third behind Alphabet Soup and Louis Quatorze in a thrilling 3-way photo finish in the 1996 Breeders’ Cup Classic at Woodbine.
Back at the barn, Cigar stood facing the back of his stall, as if he knew he had lost. Allen and Madeleine Paulson stopped by for a final visit before heading off to dinner, but Mott remained. For several minutes, he stared almost hypnotically into Cigar’s stall. When he spoke, his voice couldn’t hide the emotions that were obviously building up inside him. This was no time to be dwelling on defeats or having any regrets that Cigar’s career did not end in triumph. The only images Mott was seeing as he stared into the stall were of cheering crowds and magnificent victories.
“There’s nothing I can say about Cigar that can tell you how I feel about him and the whole experience,” Mott said in a quiet monotone voice. “There’s no reason that getting beat a short head would make me feel any differently about him. I’d be pretty damn greedy if I did or if I had any ill feelings about anything. When we decided to run him again this year I knew as a trainer that trying to have a repeat year was going to be a tough task come Breeders’ Cup time. He just lost that little step, that little turn of foot, and that’s been the difference. Before, he could have overcome having to go five-wide. Today, he just couldn’t…he couldn’t overcome it.”
So ended the remarkable career of Cigar.
Garden Party
Someone once asked me what was my most special moment in racing? Well, needless to say, there are dozens to choose from. But one that ranks right up there at the top did not even occur at a racetrack — or a training center or a breeding farm. It occurred at, of all places, Madison Square Garden.
Shortly after Cigar’s retirement, Madeleine Paulson announced that Cigar would be honored and paraded at the National Horse Show at the Garden on Nov. 2, 1996. She had a close association with the Equestrian world and wanted to show Cigar off to her “horsey” friends and to a whole new audience.
No one knew how they were going to react, not being followers of Thoroughbred racing. But they were horse lovers first and foremost. Mott was not exactly enamored with the idea of vanning Cigar into the heart of Manhattan, and for good reason. It surely had never been done before and the thought of bringing a champion racehorse into this strange environment with masses of people, taxi cabs, and blaring horns seemed absurd. Most everyone else was skeptical to say the least. But Madeleine was determined to pull it off and actually arranged for Cigar to have a police escort and for Seventh Avenue to be closed to traffic for approximately 20 blocks.
Madison Square Garden went all out to make this a success. They invited comedian Bill Cosby, members of the New York Rangers and Knicks, and brought in the Knicks’ cheerleaders and the Budweiser Clydesdales to lead Cigar’s van through the streets of the city to the Garden.
Cigar traveled from Belmont Park to Manhattan in a full-sized van, with a huge color mural on both sides depicting the horse in action. Next to the mural in large blue print with white stars was the name“Cigar.” Above it against a red background were the words “Champion and Horse of the Year,” and below it, “America’s Racehorse.”
The van met up with the Knicks cheerleaders, the Clydesdales, and other participants on a quiet side street several blocks from the Garden. There, the proceedings were organized by MSG officials. Lining the street were a number of fans, several holding posters and banners. One of the posters read: “To the Great Cigar. Thanks for the Memories.”
Outside the Garden, groups of school children gathered, waiting to get a glimpse of the great Cigar. Inside the arena, more than 16,000 people awaited Cigar’s entrance prior to the Horse Show, having no idea what to expect.
By now, Seventh Avenue was closed, and it was an eerie sight looking down one of New York City’s busiest avenues and seeing nothing, not a single car in both directions. When everyone was organized the Cigar parade commenced. With bagpipers, the Knicks cheerleaders, the New York City Mounted Police Corps, and the Clydesdales leading the way, the procession turned down Seventh Avenue to the quizzical looks of passersby, who gawked at the huge, ornately decorated horse van and its odd entourage.
Outside the Garden, Jerry Bailey posed for photos with the children. Finally, the van arrived and Bailey, decked out in Allen Paulson’s silks, hopped aboard and gave Cigar several reassuring pats on the neck. Looking east on 33rd Street, it was quite a sight seeing the van with the Empire State Building as a backdrop. Cigar peered out at the strange surroundings and then was led into the bowels of America’s most famous arena by Mott and assistant trainer Tim Jones.
At 2 p.m., Bill Cosby came riding in on a horse. After dismounting, he held a microphone directly in front of ringmaster Barry Kiger’s coach horn. As a musical crescendo filled the Garden, the crowd erupted in applause in anticipation of Cigar’s entrance.
Cigar parading at Madison Square Garden
When Cigar made his appearance, with Bailey aboard, everyone rose and saluted the champion. Bailey then rose slightly in the saddle, and Cigar, as if on cue, broke into a graceful canter worthy of any champion show horse. The crowd went wild. With Cigar striding majestically around the arena as if part of the Horse Show, the public address announcer bellowed: “Ladies and gentlemen, this is Cigar!”
Bailey then brought Cigar to the middle of the arena, where he was draped in a blanket of red, white, and blue flowers and then presented with baskets of carrots and apples by members of the Rangers and Knicks, including Hall of Fame Ranger Rod Gilbert. After the speeches, Bailey dismounted and Cigar was led around the arena by Mott, as a flurry of flashbulbs popped all around the Garden.
Mott turned the horse over to Jones, who continued to lead him around. Then the lights in the arena went dark, and a single spotlight shone down on Cigar. When a solitary trumpet began playing “Auld Lang Syne” I have to admit I lost it. Soon after, the entire band joined in, adding to the emotional impact and ending the proceedings with a flourish. Standing on the floor of the arena in the dark, I tried to wipe away the tears before the lights came back on. When they did, I turned around, and almost everyone in the seats was wiping their eyes.
That was the single most emotional moment I’ve ever experienced in racing, perhaps in part because Cigar, those closest to him, and myself, were so far removed from the world of racing that the moment transcended the sport and seemed surreal.
Afterward, Jones said. “It was all I could do not to break down. The whole experience brought me to tears. I really believe he knew what was going on and he put on quite a show for everyone. When they played that song it was a joyous moment. But it was also very sad because I knew this was really the end.”
Cigar’s greatness was felt as much as it was seen. Just ask anyone who was there when he rocked the grandstand at Arlington Park winning his 16 th consecutive race. It was the same from Suffolk Downs to Belmont Park. Just ask anyone who was there when Cigar showed the world what a champion is made of in far off Dubai or when he came charging down the stretch on battle-weary legs at Woodbine or when he shook the hallowed walls of Madison Square Garden.
Cigar enjoying his Bluegrass retirement at the Kentucky Horse Park in Lexington.
Although Cigar’s accomplishments and statistics speak of greatness, they are just one aspect of his legacy. He took the torch passed to him by Holy Bull and made thousands of new racing fans around the world. He made believers out of skeptics. He made poets and artists out of 7-year-olds and 70-year-olds. He made people cheer and he made people cry.
But most of all, he made the earth move.
Photos courtesy of Breeder’s Cup Ltd, Racing Post, Steve Haskin and Sarah Andrew.
Racing historian, author, and award-winning retired journalist for the Daily Racing Form and The Blood-Horse, Steve Haskin was inducted into the National Museum of Racing Hall of Fame’s Media Roll of Honor in 2016. Known for his racing knowledge and insightful prose, he has been an exclusive contributor to Secretariat.com since 2020.
Cigar’s personal grooming brush
COLLECTOR’S NOTE: This simple wooden grooming brush has the special distinction of being the personal brush regularly used on racing champion Cigar. The oval brush bears both Cigar’s name and testament to his distinguished stature as a racing superstar, with remnants of hair still embedded within its well-worn bristles.
Available for purchase, inquiries welcome!
Amo los caballos, aunque nunca pude tener uno. Cuando Cigar corrió en Belmont park no pude apostar por el, y me dolió mucho porque por primera vez quería ir a verlo. Mi hermoso caballo, Cigar😭💐💐💐💐💐💐👏👏👏👏⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
A wonderful article ! I had the honor of seeing Cigar paraded at the Parade of Champions when he was at the Kentucky Horse Park where I believe he later passed away and was buried there. Is my memory serving me correctly on that?
There won’t be any racing in Pleasanton, CA, this spring and thus no racing in northern CA until the summer fair circuit begins in June. Not happy to hear this.
FULL SERRANO…. OUT of Pincay Stakes and Saudi Cup !!! Injured…. Sadler would not go into details about it but says it is not serious but bad enough to keep him out of those 2 races…. Bummer !!!
I’m giving Gaming a mulligan, some horses don’t like Los Al—there’s that odd lip at around the hall mile pole, which is why they stay wide—he say a good trip but Getaway Car got away with soft splits, and while he opened the inside door—he also still had horse, which may have frustrated Gaming…Gaming ran too well in grade 1s, to make me toss him right now….
That’s right, Matthew. Too many punters ‘throw out the baby with the bath water’ after a disappointing run. Gaming just needs a refresher he’s been pretty active in a short period of time.
Totally understand why you wouldn’t toss him early,however,the three from his barn were bested by the better horse Saturday.
David, good to see you back!
I’m only giving up on him as Derby prospect – he isn’t good enough. I think they should try him on turf – it can’t hurt. Rank may end up finally breaking his maiden on dirt, but I no longer have expectations for him. I’m almost done with having any expectations for HAP – they’re mostly incredibly disappointing (including Spurgeon)
Yes, Glee is a wonderful filly. The Toby Keith was her first race beyond 6 1/2 F, and she won by over 10 lengths. Her BSF of 74 is very solid for a 2 year old going long for the first time. She’s had a very long year – I’m sure she’ll get a break now. It will be interesting where Steve bases her next year
January 10 is the next big day – Heart of Honor will be running in a conditions race then
Betsy, what would have happened to Robert the Bruce with that kind of attitude. Ha ha ha “If at first you don’t succeed try, try, and try again.” We’ll have no more of that defeatist talk until we’ve at least seen his first 4 crops. They’re not even three year olds!!
Yes, fingers crossed with Heart of Honor there seems a lot of promise with him.
LOL David
But I’m being realistic – HAP is not getting 4 crops; his old man was iced out after 1 crop…HAP was bred to 39 mares in his 3rd, 4th crops. That’s pathetic…but in practical terms, it means he’s not likely to have more than 30 foals each in those crops, if that. Taking into account injuries/deaths, etc….HAP is going to have very few runners…That’s a killer.
His yearlings don’t sell well …most of his offspring end up in the hands of owners who can afford those prices….these owners are usually claiming owners at minor tracks.
As long as he’s here, I’ll continue to have hope, but I have followed all his runners – and I’m discouraged; I expected a lot better
Betsy, don’t give up on Rank yet. He’s a beautiful horse, with great potential. Watching him Saturday, I notice he spotted the field at least two lengths at the break and he still finished fourth. His high action seems more typical of a grass horse to me, so that may be in the future for him. I have to wonder if his owners are pushing O’Neill to get him on the triple crown trail, whether he’s ready or not.
Linda, thanks!
I’m giving up on him as a Derby contender – he’s just not that kind of talent.
He’s got an ugly stride – very reminiscent of Skip Away, but SA could get away with it because he was so talented, so good
I do think Rank should try the turf despite having no pedigree – because I agree, his stride looks better suited for it, and also, it can’t hurt
But I think he’s going to get a long break
No, I don’t think Calumet pushed Doug -I think he really liked him that much
I’m sure time off will help him
Steve, your column brought back so many memories. Thank you. I’m so busy fixing up everything in readiness to go on holidays this Thursday. Ho ho ho We are having a mini heat wave here – 104 today. I’ve been up at 5 am for the past 4 days watering the garden in an attempt to save what I can. The grass has a dead brown hue but it’ll bounce back if we get some rain tonight.
Hopefully, Admiral Dennis performs well this in the Gun Runner Stakes this Saturday at the Fair Grounds. I’m going to make a Key Lime pie later in the week to celebrate a change in the weather. It’s not even summer yet.
Seems you have some Christmas spirit, even in the sweltering heat. I get annoyed if it’s above 50 around Christmas.
Yes, Todd the cooler the better for me as well. It has been in the high 60s the past 5 years during cool Decembers but it’s been warm to hot this year. The hottest months are usually February and March so I’m fearing horrendous bushfires and the devastation on the fauna and flora. Koalas are particularly vulnerable.
104 for Christmas? I’m sure Australia is great but I’ll stick with Northeast U.S.
Steve, I do miss a snowy Christmas it just isn’t the same. As I write it’s dropped to 60 degrees and is pouring rain. Melbourne is a place with dynamic weather changes but with climate change that is just accentuated.
The prediction for Christmas Day is 82 with rain but that could be 20 degrees higher or lower than the predictions.
Davids, even from Oz you know more about upcoming starts for horses I supposedly have my eye on (Admiral Dennis) than I do! I don’t envy you your heat spell in what is still technically spring down under. We’ve already had several snows here in the Catskills and it won’t be winter (technically) for another for another week.
Enjoy that key lime pie! I’m thinking of making oxtail stew and other savory dishes. And big red wines (I have a stash that I haven’t touched since last winter) are perfect for the holidays in colder climes.
Thanks Ms Blacktype and what a beautiful setting for Christmas, the Catskills. Oxtail soup is one of those comfort foods that takes your heart and mind back to childhood.
The Key Lime pie takes me back to childhood memories, having family holidays in Florida and trips to Hialeah Park. Happy memories.
Admiral Dennis was most impressive last time out, let’s hope there is even more improvement this time round. I try not to get too excited this early.
I would like to inquire about the grooming brush.
Where is it located and when was it last used for Cigar? What is the asking price or are you taking offers? If so, what is the current top offer?
I am wondering if it’s still available, as I see many of the comments are dated 2024.
Thank you for supplying this needed info!
A bad weekend for BB. His $700,000 purchase Kalea Bay by KD & BCC winner Authentic finished last in the $75,000 Bay Meadows Juvenil (Black Type Stakes). An Equibase figure of 29 was assigned.
Thoroughbred ownership is a tough endeavor. Imagin purchasing a horse for $700K and run it in a Black Type Stakes at a fair and it comes away with a last place finish and $450.
Do you get rid of the horse or the trainer?
Obviously the above was for humor. It’s tough game!
Hello Steve – What are your impressions from the win by Journalism in the LAF Futurity. I know in a previous article you mentioned you were concerned he changed leads late in his MSW, which is a concern going forward. His jockey, U. Rispoli in the LAF said Journalism was very professional and changed leads smoothly. I would imaging Bullard and Journalism would not be in the same prep race before meeting in the KY Derby because They share the same trainer and U.Rispoli is their go to jockey. It was mentioned in a DRF article that Journalism will get a mini break and wouldn’t run before FEB. possibly in the Robert Lewis on FEB 1. The Oaklawn series of preps was mentioned as a possibility for Journalism. Do you believe it’s likely that Journalism and Bullard would be separated from being in the same prep race before the KY Derby Steve?
He is still a work in progress. He doesnt drop down and reach out witth great extension, but is extremely professional and you cant ask a horse to run any straighter in the stretch. He also was carried wide on both turns. All in all this was a big move forward off his maiden win.. I’m still very high on him
Matthew W I wanted to thank you for observations of Journalism.
I have watched the race replay several times and find his closing kick to be impressive.
I also like his pedigree, especially no inbreeding through the first ten generations on his dam side.
Just my opinion as always but I think all of pieces are there for him to be very competitive in the upcoming Derby.
These two year olds however are still very young both physically and mentally, inexperienced and the road to the Derby is a long one.
Really can’t see being negative about any of them this early in the game. Just hopeful for safe races for all.
No where near having a list, just a few I am keeping an eye on and Journalism is one of them.
Rainy, raw day here in NE Georgia. Planning on cooking a pot of homemade vegetable beef soup in a bit. Was sleeting earlier today in my hometown back in Virginia.
Hope everyone has a nice Sunday and looking forward to Steve’s next column. He might have some thoughts about this weekend’s races.
Lynda,
I agree that an open mind should be maintained regarding young developing horses.
I gather you have no problem with a 2YO, even before its first start being held in exceptionally high regard and being labeled a star and/or potential star. But you take exception to one being regarded as average and view same as negative.
When a 2YO is constantly assigned low speed figures. It suggests it is several cuts below the best of its generation and will have to improve significantly to be competitive.
Are platforms such as Beyer & Equibase being negative about said 2YO? No!
Those platform speed figures reflect the current status of that 2YO, which can change with maturity. There is nothing wrong with a less than favorable assessment of the current status of a 2YO when all the pertinent factors are reviewed.
Lynda, have you seen “Trip to Bountiful” it’s an absolute gem. It would go well with your soup.
Davids, thanks!
Just checked and it is included on Amazon Prime!
Fantastic, Lynda. I think you will adore this film.
The feats of Cigar during 1995 and 1996 added joy to my time as an MSc student at Colorado School of Mines. I vividly remember how I would recharge after hard academic works by watching the unconquerable Cigar making history month after month.
Cigar made me a believer in his greatness after his unbelievable easy (wire to wire) win in the Pimlico Special defeating again the quintessential black stallion Devil his Due and Concern the 1994 Breeder’s Cup Classic champion.
That 1995 summer was like an easily decipherable scroll spanning east to west announcing that Cigar’s only real foe would be his own aging.
Despite all the attention drawn by Cigar’s poetic performances I never knew about his struggles with foot issues. The elating conquering of the desert by Cigar overcoming his soreness attains a colossal dimension in hindsight.
Cigar’s fighting spirit appears even greater in my mind’s eye now …!
I must confess … I cried when I first saw the adoration for Cigar at the Madison Square Garden and I fell again reading this vibrant and touching account in the matchless words of Steve Haskin.
And I wept again for not having ever flown in a private jet and realizing that I will never fly private in this life…
Wept Nelson upon getting text he died.
When a grown man weeps for not having flown on a private jet. He needs a man in the moment.
But then your disclosure must have been made for its humor value and devoid of seriousness.
There are specific occasions on which a man is allowed to weep. Missing an opportunity to fly private isn’t one of them.
Of course it is a joke … some times the frustration triggered by flights delayed or postponed for days makes you remember a song going something like “I am laughing to keep me from crying” while your vacation plans are just torn down…
Nelson, watching Man City loose to Man United when leading 1 nil at home with only 7 minutes to go made me weep, ironically. There is about 500,000,000 worth of football talent in that team and they do schoolboy mistakes to lose a vital match.
Pep Guardiola nearly pulled out the remaining hairs on his head.
My take on the Los Al Futurity
Kudos to Journalism !!! He ran a powerful race and Mike Mc Carthy has two “Very Good” runners in Journalism and Bullard. Early fractions in this race were soft helped his cause but when asked to accelerate that he did. Being by Curlin should get better with age. Looks to have a bright future. Hope he stays healthy
Gaming: If there was one thing I did not want to see with him in this race was for him to be pushing the pace. I feel this is not the right running style for him. He should be more mid pack. Baffert better figure this out with this horse or he will be seeing a lot more races from him like this. Also I do not like the way he is working this horse when in company with another horse. He always has him on the outside of the other horse and he lets him run evenly with the other horse instead of just letting him hook up and then just letting him blow by him. A lot of the works show the other horse beating him at the wire. Unless things change I see a mixed future for this horse.
Getaway Car. Not sure what plans he (Baffert) has for this horse but it does not look like this horse has the stamina to run on the frontend for more than a mile. Maybe a change of running style (closer possibly?!?!?) But definitely not KD material with his current running style. Could possibly be a miler.
Rank …. Unfortunately I do not think this horse is good enough to run with the best 3 year olds. If there is a race he should have excelled in it would have been this race. Fractions were soft and he saved ground in this race but when he came to the stretch he had nothing. Mike Relva (Yawn) I think he took your advice and slept on this one !!! As you would put it LOL
Mellencamp … This horse showed nothing in this race. If Baffert can’t figure out what makes this horse tick he looks to be an “expensive” dud … And I don’t mean milk dud !!!
Which of the three is modest?
None of the BB’s that raced yesterday in the LAF are KD material. Journalism toyed with them until the 3/16 pole and opened up to win by daylight.
BB has only one training style, speed, speed and more speed. Regardless of pedigree, his horses are taught to go to the lead and run as fast and as far as possible. It’s a style/formula from his QH days. When his horses lose, some of his backers start second guessing his training style.
He’s a factory trainer.
Gaming gets a mulligan, for me—many two year olds run dull races, after a big Breeders Cup run….Gaming is big framed and LOOKS like a distance horse, and he has a good burst—we didn’t see that Saturday..
Not sure what you mean by “modest” but already said that “one” is not derby worthy and the other “two” the jury is still out. Now, unless there are changes to their running styles they also will not be worthy for the derby. Remember Counter one race does not make a champion and there are a lot more races before the KD is here. A lot can change between now and then, Journalism took a baby step toward that end yesterday but remember it was a small field and soft early fractions but to his credit he took advantage of both and ran very well yesterday,
“It was a small field and the early fractions were soft”.
That should have benefitted Gaming and GAC…..just like most other stakes races where he has at least 2 or 3 runners in such races where they control the pace.
Gaming had 6 weeks between races with four published works. Same with GAC. They got beat by a much better horse. No excuses for their performances
Already owned yesterday Down regarding being wrong. Where’s ‘John’? Lol
“If there was one thing, I didn’t want to see is him pushing the pace,”
D/stretch,
Your quote above suggests that a Gaming victory was contingent on a specific scenario. The colt had previously won a G1 and was runner up in the BCJ the creme de la creme of G1, 2YO races.
With the exception of misfortune and given Gaming’s record. He should have been able to win the Los Al futurity from any position in relation to the pace. That’s what classy and talented thoroughbreds do.
There was resistance to Journalism’s challenge suggesting that despite his RR he isn’t as good as same.
I was never of the opinion that Gaming was as talented as most had assessed. I focused on his ride mechanic particularly late in his races and I did not see serious router. But who am I? just another average Joe evaluator.
There wasn’t any resistance to Journalism challenge.
Steve did you know Ritchie Allen? He loved Horse Racing….42oz bat! Hit a legendary home run that the shortstop nearly caught! I was surprised he was not in the Hall…well he’s in now! I was a big Giants fan, Allen was my favorite non-Giant…
He was my favorite player. I went to every Phillies game at Shea stadium He acrually was John Velazquez’ first agent. I interviewed him at Aqueduct.
The Springboard Mile isn’t a KD prep that many would regard as likely produce a major contender. I have done deep dive into the whether a horse form Springboard Mile has ever hit the board in the KD. However, the subsequent achievements of two participants in the Listed Stakes indicates it shouldn’t be dismissed.
in 2012 Will Take Charge was caught late by the 99/1 Texas Bling that triggered a $2500 Exa, $18K Tri and a $94K Super. Will take Charge contested all 3 legs of the TC and was defeated by a combined 45 1/4L.
After that shellacking, Will Take Charge like a Phoenix rose from the TC ashes with the removal of the blinkers to secure the Eclipse for Champion 3YO.
In 2020 a Mineshaft colt closing form 10L last won the Springboard Mile as a last out debut winner. That colt was Senor Buscador who recently won the Saudi Cup, the world’s richest race
The 2024 winner of the Springboard Mile will be dismissed given the history of the race in relation to the KD. A 2YO that is undefeated in 3 Starts on dirt, whilst recording wins over 5F, 6 1/2F & 8F at 3 different venues, has to be considered more than just average, despite its low-speed figures.
Coal Battle is a closer who has never had decent pace to run at in any of his wins. It will be interesting to see how he performs when the pace upfront is fast. His 5th generation has Seattle Slew in abundance.
Yes, I like the Coal Fronts and Coal Battle looks like a two turn horse with a quick turn of foot. Let’s hope he keeps progressing.
There wasn’t another two turn race for Journalism until the Lewis, in February, so they ran him third time in seven weeks—second time two turns—-he looked incredible, being saddled….he takes a few strides to get in gear, he has plenty of stamina….87 Beyer—coming into the winners circle he certainly looked like he was in a race–he looked somewhat spent—their plan is next race The Robert Lewis….
I mentioned in a post that he hits the ground hard. That tendency will sap a lot of energy in route races.
Correct!
Well I don’t know about that, but I DID notice that incredible maiden winner Patch Adams—his stride is a dirt stride, doesn’t hit the ground hard at all, in front….if he can route he could be something special….
I agree.
But my interest lies in barn made Hot Property a winner around 2Turns on debut.
Into Mischeif bred 216 mares in 2021 that yielded a reported 172 live foals. there must be a stallion with much lesser opportunities that has a big horse in the shadows.
barn mate
Hi Matthew – Journalism certainly didn’t dissapoint. I like the way he breaks sharp from the gate. The 87 Beyer is a good progression from his last win. He’s only going to get better. Save the triple Beyer for the KY Derby. I love that he can be tactical or come off the pace like he did in his MSW win. The 7 week spacing to the Robert Lewis should give Journalism plenty of time to recover from his win. Rispoli said Journalism was very smooth in changing leads. Exciting times ahead for Journalism and his backers on the KY Derby trail. You would think Bullard would target a different prep than Journalism. They share the same trainer and Jockey. M. McCarthy has two good ones in his barn.
I was just outside the winners circle, and said “Somebody check that horse’s ID, he looks like a three year old!” That got a big laugh—he sort of “lumbers” along, takes a few strides to get into gear—but the stamina is there….at the quarter pole it briefly looked like he was spinning his wheels, but he did that in his maiden win so I was not worried, this is a nice horse..
I am of the opinion that the last two paragraphs of a post below merit being reposted.
For the fans, of journalism. If in fact, he lingers around his ML of 6/1. You can set the mortgage.
There is no need to fear BB’s entrants. The trainer is no magician and his entrants are modest.
Well, whatever is the monthly mortgage and assuming my advice was taken. The fans of Journalism will have their mortgage payment for approximately 3 months without going into their pockets.
This was an easy call. Gaming was assigned an Equibase figure of 103 for his 2nd place finish in the BCJ. Journalism was assigned the same figure for his MSW win that featured faster internal fractions albeit on a different date.
Gaming was one pace in the final furlong of the BCJ whilst Journalism was full of run in the last furlong of his win. In fact, his stride mechanics was best close to home suggesting he was just warming up.
Some folks were of the opinion that just because BB has won the Los Al Futurity 14 times. One of his 3 entrants would have emerged winner. As stated above I considered his entrants modest at best.
For those who see BB as some kind of Godlike figure and/or idol in Thoroughbred Racing. He isn’t!
One has to look no further than the 2019 KD
Game Winner- Champion 2YO, bred to run all day and early favorite for the KD.
Roadster – Impressive winner of the SA Derby whilst defeating Game Winner
Improbable – Post time favorite in the absence of Omaha Beach.
None of the above hit the board in the original order of finish.
BB has had the KD post time favorite 9 times and only AP and Justify emerged with the win. Both were the best of their generation.
BB’s win margin in his 6 KD wins is just over 1L.
In the recently concluded KDFP #2. Barnes trained by BB who was a last out MSW winner over 5 1/2F, emerged as 2nd choice in the wagering behind ALL Others.
When will this idol worshiping end?
Enough, Counter Point. The guy wins at a 25 percent clip, I believe. When people tout BB’s horses, it’s not “idol worshiping”, it’s looking at cold, hard facts.
And it seems disingenuous to refer to any Grade 1 winner as “modest.”
Thank You Ms Blacktype… enough said with your statement.
I fully understand your endorsement. I have provided some context below
OK!
MB,
My apology for the offence taken it was not my intent.
Explain to me what part of Bezos wasn’t treating BB like a Godlike figure.
The colt had not yet made start and was listed as a betting interest in the KD Future Pool. Which other trainer has ever had such a betting interest? None!
From recollection $30K was wagered on the unraced colt who finished off the board on debut. After winning his 2nd start, his 3rd was in the Lexington where he finished last by 42 1/2L.
Only one regarded as a Godlike figure will garner such that kind of support in a sport of glorious uncertainties.
During 2024 our gracious host suggested that BB could sent his 2nd string and easily defeat horse on the other coasts. That inferred the trainer was so far ahead of another trainer he doesn’t ne to send his best to win KD preps.
Wynstock as 2nd stringer and winner of the Los Al Futurity was directed to the Southwest, As the 4th choice in the betting he finished last by 28 1/2L.
Imagination a 2nd stringer was directed to the Preakness. As the 4th choice in the betting, he finished 7 of 8 by 15 1/2L
The claim that BB can just sent his 2nd stringers anywhere and they will emerge victorious suggest a kind of invincibility no other trainer possess. What part of that isn’t worshiping.
I call it as I see it. my comments are never intended to offend but rather to enlighten.
A G1 winner and runner up in the biggest 2YO race in the country was comprehensively beaten by a last out MSW winner. That equates to modest!
Storm The Court won the G1 BCJ and secured the Eclipse for Champion 2YO. In 26 subsequent starts he never won a race. A G1 winner can be labeled modest.
Agree Counter.
Wrong! Yesterday ‘John’ doing his/her worship prior to the race. Three horses of one trainer in a five horse field and lost!
Get real Ms. Blacktype! Some nearly foam at the mouth in December proclaiming certain horse being next TC winner. Wash,rinse,repeat.
Dominant performance by Journalism in the LAF to win by 3 lengths going away. Rispoli had Journalism up close to stalk the pace which certainly worked out for him. He was striding out at the wire, so Classic distances will be fine for Journalism. M. McCarthy has 2 excellent colts that are serious KY Derby contenders, Journalism and Bullard . I expect Rispoli to ride both up to the KY Derby and you would think those 2 will not be in the same prep races. I’m fortunate and excited to have bet Journalism at 52-1 in KDFW2. He’s certainly #1 on my rankings after that performance.
You are in a strong position with your referenced wager Let’s hope the Curlin colt stay healthy.
Journalism was impressive today. Steve, I don’t envy you having to make sense of the top 3YOs at this point. The horses I liked most before the Breeders’ Cup Juvenile (East Avenue, Chancer McPatrick, and Gaming) have all shown themselves to be vulnerable, at least once. So I shuffled my top 12 or 15 today and came up with a new number 1 — Patch Adams, who looked really imposing in his second and winning start at Churchill Downs Nov. 30. Journalism is also right up there.
Happy holidays to everyone!
Poor Stiletto Boy has anyone ever seen a sadder story than what the owner and trainer are doing to this horse who clearly should have already been retired to old friends today he trailed at 43-1 sad sad handling of the former grade one winner please retire him 🙏
Agreed!
Rank was my selection today, however seems a few others were wrong as well. Lol
I sure was wrong
Give him a break and try him on turf…
Hopefully Heart of Honor won’t disappoint
Hope he rebounds and remains on dirt. Yes, Heart of Honor. Referring to others who boasted the other three were a lock. Lol
What’s the point of keeping him on the dirt for now? He’s just not good enough….even if he ends up breaking his maiden on dirt. Maybe on turf he’ll be a good horse / even though he’s not bred for it
HAP, I fear, is going to end up like his sire…but not Japan
Ok, maybe turf try. As for HAP, hoping he remains here.
Anything, at this point – they can always put him back on dirt
I’m being pessimistic, but also realistic. Breeders abandoned Honor Code after one crop had run, and HAP suffered for that (39 mares bred the last 2 years). At least he had Glee over the weekend, but he’s not going to get a long rope….
Betsy, I’ve been really busy finishing off things at work before going on holidays this Thursday. Don’t give up on Rank. He’s only a 2 year old.
Glee must have made you smile.
Well JJ left the door open, for Gaming, and carried Journalism put some….but that big bull likes a wide rally!
Way to go, Journalism! I hadn’t seen him run before but was intrigued based on the comments folks have posted. I liked his looks a lot, so he became my pick. I look forward to seeing where he goes from here!
Just watched replay. 3.5 lengths. Had a strong stretch kick.
Journalism!!! Will not get 5/2 on this horse for a while. The BB trio were gasping for air at the 1/8 pole.
Lol
Journalism looks incredible..he must already weigh 1200 lbs…..Rank and Gaming both look very good!
Come on Matthew!
Your assessment of very good needs revision.
I was standing right in front of them being saddled, and reported what I saw, cmon, man! A horse can look very good and not win!
My sincere apology,
I somehow connected your reference to their respective performances
Gotcha, ‘Facts….I enjoyed your posts….I enjoy everyone on this site…
Off topic I know:
Saw 2 photos that were taken this morning of the Curlin-Beholder colt that sold for 4 mil on a training track (guessing Florida). Very impressive, filled out nicely. A darker chestnut now than when he was auctioned. Guess giving time to mature was a good decision. Still no name and no timetable on when he ships to CA and Mr B’s stable.
Lynda,
Still waiting on this one. Curlin’s (IMO) seem to get better with age. Wonder is Baffert will get this one in time to get ready for the Derby? What make you think he is in Florida?
DTS, it looked like Florida rather than California and I had read awhile back that he was staying at a training center in Florida rather than shipping to CA. As I recall no mention of a set back, just needed some time to mature.
No idea when he will be ready to race. Could be another Justify maybe?
Not showing up on Zedan web page yet.
If and when I learn more will post.
Thanks
I saw her colt a few years ago—QB 1…..
he was enormous…
Beholder was big—we’ll see…..
MW, I think this colt looks more like Beholder than Curlin.
When was the last time two HOTY combined to produce a champion?
This colt was bred for its potential sale appeal and not to be good racehorse.
Counter Point
Beholder was not HOTY. Her Eclipse honors do include 2 Year Old Dirt Filly, 3 Year Old Dirt Filly, Older Dirt Female (twice).
In the history of the Eclipse HOTY, the following fillies/mares have won HOTY:
Harve de Grace
Zenyatta
Rachel Alexandra
Azeri
Lady’s Secret
All Along
Moccasin
Busher
Twilight Tear
Regret
Beldame
Imp
To your point, none have been bred to a male HOTY other than Rachel Alexandria who was bred to Curlin and produced Jess’s Dream who is now deceased. Rachel nearly died from foaling complications after the birth of Rachel Valentina and Ms Banke decided to retire her.
65 degrees…will go down and get as good a look as I possibly can, on the five horse Futurity field, I say as good as I can because I’ve lost 50% of my right eye’s sight! I’m only looking for calmness, no tail swishing or ears going back and forth, looking for calm walking! I don’t like horses “on their toes”, either…..Bob has these over a barrel! I would like to see a horse finishing—later tonight is the Champion of Champions Quarter Horse Race, and they have a great field!….
(50% of my LEFT eye sight!)….
Matthew,
Hope your eyesight issues are temporary
Am praying….was sudden, has been three weeks….
MW, prayers that your eyesight will return.
Thank you ! At this point I’m welcoming prayers, I cannot read one letter on the eye test chart! Severely limiting….
I hope you get it thoroughly checked out Matthew, and it heals quickly.
I remembered you in my prayers last night, Matthew, and I will continue to pray that your eyesight improves. Best wishes to you.
Matthew, I hope you have been given a referral to a specialist and have had various tests done. There are numerous possibilities for sudden loss of vision.
The best of wishes, you’ll be right.
Well, today is the Baffert Futurity. Opps, I mean the Los Al Futurity. You would have to use all ten fingers and four toes to count the number of times Bobby B has won this race and today he is loaded. Gaming comes into this race with a very impressive record having finished ahead of the best two year olds in the country in the BC Juvenile….all except one, Citizen Bull. And where is Citizen Bull? Is he sitting this out? Would he then become ‘Sitting Bull’?
Satire aside I look for Getaway Car to getaway and win…opps, I done it again.
Yawn! Don’t sleep on Rank.
I can’t believe Rank & Mellencamp are the same odds on the ML
John,
I see one of the Baffert’s to win also. Unless he becomes a last minute scratch still see Mellencamp in the race. Still see him and Getaway Car going to the front and Gaming tracking behind. I am thinking more and more Rank is going to push the issue which I hope this happens as it would allow Gaming to track behind those three.
I don’t think Rank will press the pace…the only reason he did in the race with Journalism is because it was assumed Mellencamp would get an easy lead otherwise. He had never run on the pace until then
Rank is tractable – so unless for some reason he’s impossible to control, I think it’s likely he’ll sit 3-5 lengths off the pace
Crazy!! I had been waiting for San Saba to be added at William Hill and he just was at 55-1; before I could get my bet in, he went to 35-1; he is now 28-1, and probably is going lower today…There must have been some serious money on him immediately, I don’t think my $40 bet moved the odds that much!
He is working great, just need to see maiden race, maybe at Santa Anita…
Biggy, I agree! The horse hasn’t even started yet.
$725 K purchase. Agree, this ‘Justify’ horse has been working lights out.
Cigar, a horse for the ages. I recall the day he lost in the Pacific Classic to snap his 16 race winning streak.
On another note, Santa Anita’s opening day is shaping up to be a great day of racing. 94 nominations including Mystik Dan, Bentornato, and Full Serano are among an array of thoroughbred stars getting ready to compete. Should be a fantastic day of racing!
Excited for Journalism chance to upset overwhelming FAV Gaming in the Los Al Futurity today. Journalism will be rolling late and the long Los Al Stretch should enhance his chance to reel in Gaming in the stretch. I’m glad to have bet Journalism at 52-1 in KDFW2. I will single Journalism in my late P4 at Los Al. A lot of people will certainly be singling Gaming. Gaming was all out in the stretch to try to reel in longshot Citizen Bull in the BC Juvenile and couldn’t make up any ground on him in the stretch. This race IMO is not a slam dunk win for Gaming which the odds board will reflect with Gaming likely being bet down to less than even money. Informative article on Cigar Dteve. I enjoyed watching Cigar race and often win with Jerry Bailey hand gesturing holding a Cigar as he crossed the finish line.
Speed figures continue to be puzzling to me.
Coal battle won the Springboard Mile in 1:39 plus which the average winning time for the Listed Sakes. He was assigned an Equibase figure of 97.
First resort won the Jockey Club Stakes in 1 :43.01 the fast time since Super Saver set the SR of 1:42.83. Fists Resort was assigned a 92
Poster finished5 1/2L ahead of Coal Battle in an 8f AOC on turf at Keeneland. Poster returned to win the Remeb and was assigned a 97.
Regarding Coal Battle, he provided some early Christmas shopping money. But along the way his continuous lugging tendency caused some anxious moments late in the stretch. How much better would this colt be is he learns how to keep straight course?
A very nice little colt whose career 5 starts have been at 5 different tracks. He is undefeated in 3 starts on dirt and unplaced in 2 on turf. He appears to be a cut below KD standard, but he will reassess should his connections direct him to one of the major KD preps.
Counter, I agree Coal Battle is a nice horse, but that 14 second last quarter doesn’t bode well for him as a Derby horse. Let’s hope the owners aim for races he can win, like multiple stakes winner and millionaire Valentine Candy.
He’s impressive and can improve. Realise he’s not in the ‘correct’ barn for your taste.
Mike, I didn’t say a word about his barn — just the final eighth (I initially said quarter; he’d be a world beater if he rain a quarter mile in 14 seconds!).
He did close well over Speed King, who was only making his second start.
He has time.
He was lugging in badly, and his lead change was late. That might have negatively impacted the time for the final furlong.
Contrarian –
A person who takes a contrary position or attitude.
A person who opposes or rejects popular opinions.
I have been referred to as the top contrarian on this site. I hardly believe the characterization was meant to flattering. But it is certainly less damming than the characterization of harboring ill-will for the supporters of this space. There was also a claim that I harbor the opinion that I am smarter than everyone else on this blog. That claim is even more baffling as I cannot see how such an assertion could be effectively portraited though opinions.
I look in the marrow each day and those characterization are not associated with person reflected.
How does merely positing opinions in and opinion forum lead to such unflattering characterizations?
Thoroughbred Racing is a sport of glorious uncertainties. It is beset by a linty of talent evaluation and handicapping theories. Very often emotions inhibit objectivity in both processes.
Given the nature of the sport, there will always be varying opinions. All engaged in the process of talent evaluation and handicapping can be labeled as a constrain at some point.
Is it my agenda to oppose all opinions. Certainly not! I merely provide a perspective on facts/issues I consider pertinent, that might not have been overlooked by a particular contributor. The combination of viewpoints can lead to a more comprehensive handicapping and evaluation process.
My handicapping and talent evaluation process takes into account a lot of factors, many would consider irrelevant. But given there is no set blueprint regarding how to evaluate young and developing horses. Just about any process can be effective. Even a perceived flawed process can produce the desired result.
As I have stated before. There must be place for dissenting/opposing views in a spot of glorious uncertainties.
Great! Agree regarding ‘no set blueprint’ with development of young horses. As we know,some trainers push too soon.
Good day, Counter Point
First off, my “Contrarian” reference was a “tongue in cheek” comment that was not to be taken seriously. Over the years, we have exchanged countless comments on the sport of horse racing and have gained a mutual respect for each other’s opinions, or at least I thought we did. On several occasions, I have pointed out your ability to point out longshots, and your strong command of the English language, which has always impressed.
It appears I’ve ruffled a few feathers of late, and for that I offer a sincere apology.
That said, I feel it’s time for me to step back for an extended period of time to let the dust settle, so to speak.
At this time, I would like to wish a happy holiday season to Steve and to his loyal followers that have made this site the best source of information on the sport of horse racing.
Best of luck to all moving forward on the Kentucky Derby trail.
Saying things inadvertently is a fault I’m sure we can all attest to. Most people have well intentions as I’m sure you had. Try not to step back too long, the 2025 KD trail is right around the corner. Happy Holidays to you as well.
Well, I can’t find the comment, but a few days ago someone spoke well of Coal Battle’s chances in the Springboard Mile, so whoever did that–congratulations! He’s a grand-looking horse, too. I always liked Coal Front.
Yes, I remember that comment. It was posted by none other than Counter Point.
Hat off to CP for l picking another winner. Coal Battle nailed my Pick, Speed King, at the wire.
To get everyone in the holiday spirit, I would highly recommend listing to Myriah Carey’s “All I want for Christmas is you”. Her incredible five octave vocal range is something to behold. Being a guitar enthusiast, I especially like the base guitar thumping in the background which certainly adds a lot to the song, IMO.
For those that haven’t heard “All I want for Christmas is you” simply goggle in Myriah’s name and the song title, and the video of her singing the song will come up.
Enjoy.
A classic!
Yes indeed, arlingtonfan, a classic, in every sense of the word.
Never liked Carey, however Cigars’ story partially lost here unfortunately.
Congratulations, Mike, you’ve replaced Counter Point as the top “Contrarian” on this site.
BTW, it’s hard to believe that Myriah Carey’s voice displeases you. But, to each his own.
Have a nice holiday season Mike.
It’s called an opinion, Bill. Difficult to imagine how anyone works friggin Carey into a story about a revered horse as Cigar.
So ironic, lol
I don’t celebrate Christmas, but I like Christmas songs…I don’t like Mariah Carey, and I don’t like that song.
Mike, Glee won the Toby Keith stakes at RP by over 10 lengths…so another nice SW for this daughter of HAP. This was her first time stretching out – she’s such a tractable filly
Her final time was 1:40.16
Springboard Mile. 1:39.26
We agree on that! Don’t like her or that song. Thanks for info on Glee.
You’re welcome !
Bill, I enjoy all Christmas music from Mariah to Manheim Steamroller. Also enjoy watching classic Christmas movies.
It is just not the same now that I live in Georgia, my Daughter and Grandaughters living in Florida, my family back home in Virginia and since my parents passed away.
Music and movies brighten the Holiday Season now and bring to mind so many precious memories of Christmas past.
The Remington Springboard Mile, with 10 Derby points going to the winner, is set to go off at 11:26 eastern time. Speed King, in p/p 3, wired the field when breaking his maiden at Churchill, going 6 furlongs in 1:10.20, drawing off by 2 1/4 lengths, earning an Equibase speed figure of 92 in the process. His sire, Volatile was a sprinter but appears to have enough stamina on his dam side to be effective for at least a mile. Moving forward, it remains to be seen if Speed King will be competitive beyond a mile.
However, first things first. I like he chances to wire the Remington field.
Safe trips to all.
Speaking of that race Bill, I like Dominant Spirit to track Speed King. It’s possible Dr Ruben M may have to expend energy to get over before the 1st turn thus having lil left in reserve to finish. DS for the win.
Good evening, Kmi
Dominant Spirit’s odds, at 15-1, certainly look enticing. He was right there at the finish in his last out stakes race. He appears to be well bred, by Mohaymen, out of a Speightstown mare, and his connections are top notch.
The fact that he’s a gelding may be the only knock against DS moving forward.
Good luck Kmi.
Thanks Bill and goodluck to you also. I think his odds reflect he hasn’t won a stakes unlike the gelding Jolly Sumarai who’s at 4/1.
Excellent point, Kmi.
What am I missing?
Steve, I learned a couple of interesting things about Cigar that I wanted to share with the group.
Mrs Paulson bred Cigar and she traded him to Mr Paulson for a filly he had bred named Eliza. She won the 2 year Juvie fillies that year at the BC and won the 2 year old filly Eclipse that year.
Cigar was not named for tobacco cigars as I had always thought but for a navigational intersection for airplanes.
The derivation of Cigars name is in the column. I write about flying over it.
Yes you did. I apologize.
One thing your columns do is to awaken the curiosity in me to learn more about the horses, the connections and their story. Admittedly I am a very curious person.
Classic Causeway will enter stud next year at Pope McLean’s Crestwood Farm. He will stand for $6,500 with a live foal stands and nurses guarantee. He seemed to have disappeared for a bit and I had asked if anyone knew where he might have gone.
West Saratoga has been sold for 375,000 to RRR Racing in Dubai for evaluation and possible future racing under Doug Watson. The 3 year old by Exaggerator placed 12th in the 2024 Kentucky Derby.
I believe I wrote a similar comment on an earlier column, probably at the time of Cigar’s passing. I too was at the 1995 Breeders’ Cup (can’t wait for it to return to Belmont) and at MSG – I know I have photos somewhere of Cigar in the spotlight. However, my favorite memories of Cigar were slipping him Mrs. Pastures in his paddock at the Horse Park at night after the staff was gone (we always stable next to his paddock when we’re there).
I also liked the note that the Eclipse ceremony was at the Hotel Del – I’m originally from San Diego and Easter at the Prince of Wales Grille was our family tradition.
R.I.P. Lemon Drop Kid – will miss seeing you at LE.
Maybe you can solve a mystery for me. There is a discrepancy at the Horse Park between Cigar’s headstone and statue as to what Tom Durkin’s call was at the Breeders’ Cup. The statue says “Incomparable, invincible, unbeatable”. The stone says “unconquerable, invincible, unbeatable”. I’ve listened to the replay and it’s hard to tell. Which is right?
Lemon Drop Kid and Always Dreaming now run with the Heavenly Herd.
Condolences to connections and their grooms.
Sad news to hear about these 2. Steve I know that Always Dreaming was a big favorite of yours. Was unaware until I read the article of his passing that he was moved to Oklahoma. Condolences to the parties involved.
Always Dreaming was a beautiful Thoroughbred. I too recall how high Steve was on him winning the Kentucky Derby. Sad he passed at a young age (10) from the dreaded colic.
I was so sorry to read he died. He’ll always be special to me because he won the last Kentucky Derby my mom and I got to share together.
arlingtonfan, surely a memory you will treasure forever.
Always Dreaming is gone? He was only 10. Lemon Drop at least attained a great age (28). The one I’m dreading is the passing of Silver Charm, who is 30 this year.
The article on Always Dreaming stated he had a bout of colic, spent 4 days in a clinic, thought all was well and suddenly ruptured. He had been standing in Oklahoma. +
Silver Charm was the first horse I watched race after my long hiatus after Ruffian broke down. He looks great for his age.
Glad to hear that, Lynda. I saw him when he was 25 at Old Friends. A very mellow horse, but still with the look of a champion.
I will always remember Lemon Drop Kid winning the Whitney in 2000. During our first visit to Saratoga, my dad and I watched that Whitney from the Saratoga apron, soaking wet in a summer downpour.
Another treasured memory.
Horses, be they the Thoroughbreds, famous or not so famous seem to touch our lives in so many ways.
By the way, Matt, I didn’t call Bill rude for having a different opinion, and I don’t appreciate you saying so
I explained below that I called him rude for his throwing the Los Al Futurity ML in my face – as if ML means anything- and implying I was not objective about Rank
Bill chose to ignore that and is playing the victim
I’m done with him, but I’m not going to let misrepresentations about me stand
Well when you say “What about Rank?”….and “Watch his last race”…..you are INVITING comment, I saw nothing wrong with you asking about his opinion…and nothing wrong with his answering you—we’re talking horses, we all can’t like the same horse all the time, I don’t see Bill “forming good taste clubs”, for people that agree with HIS PICKS…..
You’re missing the point..I don’t care that he disagrees, although yes, I think anyone who loves Journalism & automatically tosses Rank did not pay attention to the race dynamics in their meeting
Bill threw the ML at me like it means anything and he did imply I wasn’t being objective
But anyway, it’s useless to continue arguing over a minor thing
The race is tomorrow, and we shall find out more about all the runners
Hence,when stating yesterday,sometimes seems a cozy little club for a chosen few.
Just a reminder on what could be important 65K maiden race coming up tomorrow at Gulfstream Park, (R7). Based on his 2nd place finish to the highly regarded Grayscale, and listed as the 5/2 favorite, it appears Commendatore appears to be the one to beat.
I’m giving a hard look at the Godolphin homebred colt, Playa Del Mar, by Into Mischief, out of a Tiznow mare. He’s in the capable hands of William Mott and will be ridden by Edgard Zayas Jr. In addition to Playa Del Mar, there’s another homebred in the field, Gosger, that looks extremely fit with four straight bullet works. Trained by Brandan Welsh, and with Tyler Gaffalione in the saddle, Gosger could hit the wire first, at 4-1, on the M/L.
Majorca, at 3-1, with the Todd Pletcher/Irad Ortiz Jr. connection could be dangerous as well.
That said, betting Commendatore, Playa Del Mar, Gosger and Majorca in a $1.00 superfecta box might work.
Safe trips to all.
Steve -I’ve read quite a few of your articles over the years, but this one is my favorite.
Thanks very much Jay.
I had a $41 double, Beholder–Arrogate in the Breeders Cup….did not bet a penny on Chrome but was screaming for him to get there first—a guy holds $2000 in win bets on Arrogate in my face and proclaims Chrome is a dog! THAT–is rude….
Talking horses, having opinions—not rude! Everybody has an opinion, or twenty—it’s Horse Racing! I like Journalism, and there’s no way I can be objective about him I just like him lots! I also like Rank…..with the pace controlled by Bob, the objective analysis would be Gaming has them over a barrel, but I’ll still try and make a case for Journalism and Rank…..it’s a long stretch…
Keep hope alive Matthew. I’m also on Team Journalism. The long stretch should benefit Journalism. He wants longer and should be rolling in the stretch . Rank is talented and should also run well.
I just don’t think I could stomach yet another race where a horse gets away with an easy lead. If Mellencamp runs, he should also be on the pace
Well said, Matthew.
To label a person as being rude, for simply posting a different opinion on any given horse, is way out of line. I believe the oddsmaker at Los Alamitos has “objectively” set the odds which is indictive of past performances, connections, breeding, etc, etc.
Listed at 15-1, Rank deserves those double-digit odds for good reason. Conversely, Gaming is deserving of his 2/5 m/l odds for good reason as well.
As I posted in a previous comment, the Los Alamitos Futurity appears to be a two-horse race between Gaming and Journalism.
BTW, from my perspective, the bulk of the comments posted this blog are subjective in nature. There’s a fine line between being subjective and objective.
To reiterate, labeling a person as being “incredibly rude” for posting an opinion that is counter to theirs, is way out of line.
In closing, I would like to wish “Peace and Good Will” to all contributors to Steve Haskins’ Secretariat.com blog.
We are fortunate to have Steve posting his insightful articles, giving us guidance, year after year.
How to BEAT Gaming in the LOS AL Fut.
Flaven Prat (and he has done this in the past with some horses)
decides to take GAMING to the front (along with the other 2 BB horses) and run unrealistic early fractions of 21+ – 44+ 108+ 1:34+
Journalism
comes out of the gate and goes directly to the back of pack and goes to the rail sits about 10+ lengths back of the frontrunners going around the first turn. Goes full out on the far turn coming into the stretch
Rank
Runs similar to Journalism but is about 6 lengths behind the frontrunners going into the 1st turn. Again all out on the far turn coming into the stretch
In the stretch all the frontrunners collapse and Journalism and Rank dual it out down the stretch.
The reality of it all !!!
Getaway Car and Mellencamp (if he runs) goes to the front with with Gaming tracking just behind those two (unless the jockey of Rank decides to push the pace gets in front of Gaming). Rank should be sitting behind Gaming with Journalism pulling up the rear but not too far behind Rank. I expect Gaming to overtake the front two on the far turn and start pulling away in the stretch with Journalism in hot pursuit and Rank and Getaway car dueling out for 3rd.
Winner
Gaming by 2+ lengths with Journalism 2nd and coinflip for 3rd with Rank and Getaway Car. Mellencamp fades to last.
Good Luck to all who are betting this race. I will be watching from the sidelines
Rank doesn’t run similar to Journalism, though
Too be honest with you Betsy I have no idea were Rank will be in this race. What kind of race would you like to see him run here?
Oh my god, Bill, you didn’t even read my reply to you
Don’t let them intimidate you Betsy. It was a battle over semantics and the words objective and rude, which wasn’t your point, you just needed words and reached for those two. They went on and about those words, very touchy. I hope Rank wins.
Totally agree about majority opinions here are subjective—example—I like Journalism…he posts a good work, and I’m over-the-top happy about him, not looking at Gaming’s..and Rank’s..and Getaway Car’s works which were also good—no way am I being objective, I like who I like, it’s what I LOVE about this sport!
Hey Matthew
Once again, you nailed it. Posting subjective opinions on this site is certainly everyone’s right to do so. To be labeled as ” incredibly rude” for lacking objectivity relating to Rank’s last race, is downright laughable.
Best of luck moving forward, Matthew.
Happy Holidays to all.
Thanks for the memories Steve. Brought a tear to my eye. I was there for the 1995 Breeders’ Cup, spent time with Cigar during the week, and was on the track with him the morning of the race when he reared up like Pegasus and dramatically stated he was ready. I later walked over with him to the paddock for the race. Stood on the track beside Allen Paulson to greet Cigar after the race, and later got a numbered print signed by everyone in the barn. Bill Mott was a gracious host. Cigar was a special horse. And you are a fabulous writer. You captured the essence of Cigar beautifully.
Have lock of hair.
Thank you very much, George. And thank you for actually commenting on Cigar.
Mr. Haskin, no one brings stories to life better than you. Although wasn’t acquainted with connections,did spend fair amount of time with Cigar at KHP. Also, present for his last four birthdays. Upon his passing,received notification prior to reading on racing sites. He’s one of my three favorite all time horses. Again, thanks for the well deserved details and personal insights you always bring. To this day- miss him alot!
MLs are way above my pay grade.
Gaming 2/5
Journalism 6/1
There absolutely no way Gaming leaves the gates at 2/5 and the is absolutely no way Journalism leaves the gates at 6/1. There are only six entrants.
I am aware that it’s futile to compare the fractions of races on different days. However, the fractions below make for interesting analysis:
BCJ – 23.44; 47.89; 1: 12.21; 1;36.53; 1:43.01 – Gaming was one pace in the lane
MSW- 22.13; 46.22; 1:11.04; 1:36.49 – Journalism was full on run late
Journalism was off the bridle early to get into contention. But that was understandable as the half mile was completed in 46 .22. Journalism works reflect half miles in 46 & 47 handily.
Given the distance of the race and the fractions likely to be similar to the BCJ. There is no way there will be significant gap between Gaming and Journalism. The last out maiden winner has a more explosive stretch run than BB’s 3 entrants.
For the fans of journalism. If in fact he lingers around his ML of 6/1. you can set the mortgage.
There is no need to fear BB entrants. The trainer is no magician, and his entrant are modest.
True, Bob Baffert is not a magician, but his record of 14 wins in the Los Alamitos Futurity speaks for itself. To refer to Baffert’s three entrants as “modest” is puzzling to say the least. It would come as no surprise if his colts filled out the trifecta.
Just to be clear, I like Journalism a lot, but I think he’ll be up against it trying to take down Gaming.
My dear friend,
KDFP #2
Gaming – 21/1 – 6rth choice
Get Away Car – 70/1 -22nd choice
Mellencamp – not considered worthy to be a betting interest
The above suggest that Gaming is the best of the lot. The other two are modest at best.
Gaming was only able to finish 3 1/2 ahead of the fast-closing Hill Road in the BCJ. Hill Road finished 2nd to last in his previous race, was making his dirt debut and was he only entrant that finished with interest.
The Equibase figure assigned to Gaming for his BCJ effort was 103. The figure assigned to Journalism for his MSW win was 103.
My interest lies in neither colt. however, I am of the opinion Journalism is legitimate colt whilst Gaming is from a HighTech Operation in which performance is not reflective of true ability.
Counter,some contends he walks on water. I like Rank.
He may or may not win, but his US Timeform rating from his last was outstanding
I agree Journalism will be lower than 6-1—-Gaming could be 2/5 though, sitting right off the pace—he finished up well, at Del Mar vs better…..I like Journalism….
Just curious, has anyone read the book “Born To Race” by Blanche Chenery Perrin ( Penny’s Aunt)?
Found a used hardcover copy on AZON.
Supposed to be about the history of The Meadow, written before Secretariat was born.
Loved that book! I may still have a paperback copy in storage. I think CW Anderson did black and white sketches for it. And I never made the connection that the author was Penny’s aunt! As I remember it’s a novel about a filly loved by a teenage girl who runs in the Kentucky Derby – back when no filly but Regret had ever won it.
Mrs Perrin passed away in 1973 in Florida. Per the obit she was one of the first females to be become a female copywriter.
“Born To Race”, per the obituary in NY Times, was her best selling book and was based on her experiences at The Meadow owned by her late brother, Christopher T. Chenery.
She authored a number of children’s books.
Thank you for responding!
There’s another book about the history of The Meadow which you may be familiar with. It’s called Secretariat’s Meadow and is by Kate Tweedy, Penny Chenery’s daughter. It’s a large-sized book with lots of photographs. I looked it up on Amazon, where I wrote a review of it, and right now the prices are outrageous. Maybe they will come down in the future. They were very reasonable when I got my copy and later another copy to give to a friend who was a big fan of Secretariat. I didn’t know it in advance, but that copy was signed by both Kate Tweedy and Penny Chenery. My friend was amazed and delighted to see that.
Hi Jiffy,
Would love to have a copy of Secretariat’ s Meadow but the price, oh my.
I keep checking to see if it has come down.
Bill, I said you were rude because you threw the ML odds in my face – as if they mean anything – and said I wasn’t viewing Rank’s races objectively…..not because you have a different opinion
Betsy, expecting Rank to run big.
Mike, I think he will. I don’t really care if he wins or not – if he runs well, they can proceed on the Derby Trail. If not, give him a rest and try to break his maiden when he returns
Always liked Honor AP as well. With few on here,cozy little club it seems.
A cozy club with good taste !
The Los Alamitos Futurity appears to be a two-horse race between Gaming and the Don Alberto homebred, Journalism. With two strong G1 races in his resume’, and ascending brisnet speed figures (90, 99, 105) I would think the class tested Gaming is the horse to beat. Gaming’s sire line leads directly to Mr. Prospector, and his broodmare sire line leads directly to Northern Dancer. This mating cross has proved successful in producing winners of several Triple Crown winners, nineteen at last count.
For those that give some degree of credence to the X-Factor large heart concept, Gaming could be a carrier of that gene.
Bottom line, Gaming checks the most boxes as the top contender in the LA Futurity, IMO.
Safe trips to all.
I concur with your thinking here Bill. He had a nice blowout the other day. He looks the one to beat. As per my comments below in an earlier post disappointed with the field size for a grade 2 race…. But I have just thought of another reason it might have come up so small and that is the cost of vanning horses from Santa Anita to Los Alamitos.
I think you guys are seriously underrating Rank because he’s a maiden
Watch him in Journalism’s maiden breaker and tell me that Jdidn’t get a great set up after Rank did all the hard work putting Mellencamp & a long shot away.
I’m not saying Rank is going to win, but everyone going gaga over Journalism isn’t viewing that race with objective eyes
Hi Betsy
Rank has had five chances to break his maiden and has yet to do so.
In his only stakes race, (Del Mar Futurity) he was beaten 13 lengths by Gaming.
He’ll have to show a lot more in the LA Futurity than he has so far.
Good luck if you bet Rank, you’ll need it.
BTW Betsy, I noticed Gaming is 2/5 on the morning line, and Rank is listed at 15-1. So much for viewing Rank’s last race with objectivity.
The morning line says it all.
Man, what’s your problem ? You are incredibly rude …
The ML is what I expected – so what? Horses don’t care what the odds are
I’m surprised that you consider me “incredibly rude” for merely stating my opinion on Rank.
You stated, “I think you guys are seriously underrating Rank because he’s a maiden”. Why is my opinion considered “rude” for expressing an opinion on Rank and his chances in the LA Futurity.
Bill, with all due respect, you’re not looking very closely at his races
For one thing, he ran pretty well in his first two sprints – he’s not a sprinter, at all. The DM Futurity was a debacle – he was climbing all over the place
In his first star going a mile, he did everything really well – he just had no chance on a biased track and a loose on the lead horse
You didn’t watch his last against J if you think that J was so much the best, and that Rank has no shot
Apparently you missed the part where I said I’m not saying he’s going to win. What I’m saying is that this idea that J is Gaming’s only competitor is not true
There’s no need for me to respond further.
Have a nice day, Betsy.
Too bad – I’d have liked to have heard why you thought I was wrong 😂
Bill,
It appears you were displeased with my views of Patch Adams despite my declaration that the colt deserves to be held in high regards.
My assessment regarding his stride mechanics and turnover rate could prove to be meaningless. The colt could emerge to be a monster. But until that eventuality I am of the opinion he is a sprinter/miler
Regarding your referenced class test. Many impressive MSW winners are yet to be class tested. However, some have won around two turns. PA hasn’t gone further than 7F.
Journalism, Calling Card and Hot Property broke their maiden at a mile or further.
You have declared the Patch Adams is the leading KD prospect at the moment because of his 7F in 1:20 plus. Bill Mott’s Godolphin colt broke his maiden in a graded stake against winners.
Which is the more significant performance?
There are many ways to assess which colt in the leader of the pack at the moment. You have chosen speed as the pertinent measure. That spells danger.
Where does Cigar rank amongst the greats form the Northern Dancer sire line
Cigar – Palace Music – Northern Dancer (33 Starts – 16 wins)
Galileo – Sadlers Wells – Norther Dancer (8 Starts – 6 wins)
Frankel – Galilo- Sadlers Wells – Norther Dancer (14 Starts – undefeated)
Sea The Stars – Cape Cross- Green Desert-Danzig – Northern Dancer (9 stars – 8ins)
Ninjinsky – Northern Dancer – Nearctic
Are there more greats?
Was around him last nine yrs. of his life. He ranks high.
Chinook Pass-grandsire is Northern Dancer.
25:16-4-1
Longacres Racetrack (Renton, Wa)-track record in winning the Washington Stallion Stakes
Longacres-world record of 55.1 in winning the Longacres Owners Handicap
Hollywood Park-equalled the world record of 56 in winning the Meteor Handicap
Santa Anita-tied the track record of 107.3 in winning the Palos Verde Handicap
1983 Sprinter of the Year
Del Mar-won the Bing Crosby Handicap by 8 lengths
Longacres-won the Longacres Mile by 6 lengths-largest margin of victory ever.
Laffit Pincay Jr.-“Chinook Pass was the fastest horse I’ve ever rode and the fastest horse I’ve ever seen run”.
Wow, the Los Al Futurity is loaded: I expected BB to run Mellencamp, but Gaming & GC?
And Journalism & Rank? Whew
I think Mellencamp will likely be the speed…I’d like to see Rank no more than 3-4-5 lengths off the pace
What a race!
Having read they hadn’t nominated him….they must’ve put up a chunk of change, to get him in the race…..that makes sense, he put up two good half mile works….I’m bullish on Journalism, I’d like to go out to see him saddled and run….later that night is the Champion of Champions Quarter Horse Race, I had planned on attending that as well…I’ll also get a good look at Rank—and Gaming, who will go off heavily favored….
I’m guessing Mellencamp won’t go, and Getaway Card the early speed….Bob making sure the race filled, by entering the maiden….Mellencamp faded badly, in a maiden race, not like Bob to run him in a Gr2….
I was wondering about that since for sone reason no one wanted to run?
I assumed Mellencamp would run – it does seem like him, TBH…but what you said makes sense, too
It’s frustrating when jocks let horses cruise on easy leads; I hope that won’t happen here
I’m guessing Mellencamp won’t go, and Getaway Car the early speed….Bob making sure the race filled, by entering the maiden….Mellencamp faded badly, in a maiden race, not like Bob to run him in a Gr2….
Fun night, Matt!
I’m surprised Bob kept G and GC in training post-BC since this race isn’t going to affect Eclipse voting
Gaming deserves to be favored…..
Every time Bob does this it’s an easy pace, Gaming will sit an easy 2nd, and he will be double tough….I was hoping Mischief River would be entered, for more speed…as it is Journalism and/or Rank will need to stay close!..
I just want to see a strong finish, I’m not worrying about winning….
Rank was caught up in the speed duel in the race J won, and before that was mostly 4-6 lengths off the pace when he finished 2nd behind his loose on the lead stablemate, Dr Ruben M.
Journalism, I think, stayed closer to the pace last out than in his debut – for the same reason Rank was up close…they didn’t want Mellencamp being loose on the lead. So, I think both have shown that they can adjust.
Should be a fun race!
He has THREE horses in five. Lol
I am still assessing Journalism as he won a 2Turn Mile in 1:36.49. Such a time in a 2Turn mile ranks high on my list. Another stand out is how physically imposing he is as a 2YO.
The colt obviously has talent. But does his mechanics allow him to be effective over 10F against the cream of the crop?
I didn’t see the post parade but form the little I saw of his walk. There isn’t a lot of overreach in his stride. I usually look for overreach when assessing if a horse is likely to be a serious router. His stride indicates 9F max against serious routers.
The way he covers ground is bit laborious. He has to be hard ridden to get into contention and that results in his energy reserves being tapped into early. Even the most stamina blessed will be compromised in the lane with early demands on their energy reserve.
Journalism is a very big colt who hits the ground hard. An equally talent opponent that skips over the ground on light feet, should be able to easily repel his late race challenge.
Changes in 2YO occur rapidly. This colt could either prove me wrong or force me to reassess. Irrespective of which scenario plays out. He deserves the high regards in which he is held.
Th
Betsy,
You appear to harbor high expectation for Rank. I watched his 2nd place finish to Journalism several times and despite the stamina relatives in his 2nd generation. it doesn’t appear he will route effectively against the top colts. Why?
His stride mechanics is energy sapping. Even if a horse is blessed with an abundance of stamina. If the way it covers ground is inefficient, there will be an earlier than desire demand and depletion of energy recourses.
In the later phase of the Journalism race. The stride mechanics displayed by Rank left a lot to be desires. He appeared to be extremely tired and instead maintaining stride extension he had an up and down action reminiscent of his sire and grandsire.
Obviously, its early days and like most 2YO, Rank is likely to improve. But stride mechanic rarely changes. The link between stride mechanics and the management of energy recourses cannot be underscored.
I’m not trying into stride mechanics, but if you had watched that race, then you’d have seen that Rank was caught up in a speed duel. He was sent early to avoid Mellencamp getting an easy lead. Unfortunately, that long shot also engaged …
Rank did all the hard work, and still took the lead in the stretch, but Journalism sat the sweet trip and took advantage.
I do not expect Rank to be on the lead, or dueling, but a few lengths back. He’s a much better colt since he started routing
I can’t say for sure how he’ll run, but I Jace high hopes.
**have
Noted!
I will say this – at times he’s got an almost Skip Away type leg action, but it’s much smoother in his route races. I generally just think that whatever works for a horse, works
Just a few days now – we shall see!
A fan of this horse.
You have a $200K race (Los Al Futurity) for 2 year olds and only 5 entrants and 3 of those by the same trainer…. Sad state of affairs California racing is in. Were are Mandella’s, Sherriffs, D’Amato’s, Sadler’s etc… 2 year olds at? Just pathetic !!! Unless somethings start changing over there I think California racing will be extinct in 5 years !!!
And it is a Grade 2 on top of it.
Mandella, Sherriffs, d’Amato, Sadler—-have really not been noted trainers of two year olds….Shirreffs won The Derby with a 50-1 shot….Mandella almost saddled a Derby favorite (Omaha Beach)….d’Amato had longshot Stronghold, last year, I don’t recall Sadler with a Derby horse,
ever….When I was a 13 year old just getting into the sport—1972 it was—they only had one western horse—Kentuckian in the Derby, the problem in the west is they don’t have revenue from those historic Racing slots, which have fueled huge purses, in Arkansas, Kentucky and New York—Yes, there’s only five entered, yes it’s gr2….for such small numbers….the west has produced several Derby winners—
Knock on wood—I’ve heard recent talk about possible inroads, on those historic Racing slot revenue coming to California—THAT is what is needed, Horse Racing would be rocked to it’s core, if it fails, in California, the latest state-bred crop is WAY DOWN..
Where? Lol Maybe they don’t believe in pushing like some do.
Glad to see Journalism running in the Los Al Futurity this SAT. His last race was very impressive and I think he will be a major player in this race. I love his PP5. in the small 5 horse field. He is up against 3 Bafferts and Rank. Plenty of speed signed on, Rispoli should be able to come from off the pace and try to mow them all down in the stretch , I’m thrilled to have bet Journalism at 52-1 in KDFW2.
Me as well, Joe—I don’t often bet much on a futures wager, but I put up a $20 on Journalism, who stepped up around two turns!
Good luck on your futures bet Matt. I bet $40 on Journalism to win in KDFW2 and boxed him with the field. I’m really excited about Journalism in the Los Al Futurity. Gaming winning is not a foregone conclusion IMO. The pace will be honest and Journalism will be stalking IMO from the outside PP. He has a big upset chance but doesn’t need to win. A good 2nd behind Gaming would show everyone that he belongs on the KY Derby trail. They ponied up the supplement fee to get in , so you know Journalism is looking good. The longer the better for this son of Curlin.
You have more confidence in an honest pace than I do, Bob has three–he’s going to have the lead and isn’t about to challenge his own horses, he sure didn’t in the Breeders Cup….I’m half expecting on Journalism staying close early, like laying 2nd…..but even with a slow pace that long stretch can equalize things some….
Steve,
Always enjoy reading stories from you about our racing heroes of the past and especially when you have had interactions with them. The way you wrote this stories makes us feel like we are right there with you.
Keep up the great work and have a great rest of the week and weekend !!!
Thank you very much.
Love all of your articles Steve but I must say this one gave me first the chills, then the tears ( felt like i was right there in MSG) and finally a melancholy smile on my face for a magnificent thoroughbred who delighted all his followers with his accomplishments. Glad you got to experience the “wonder” of Cigar and shared it with us, Thank You
Thank you so much Diane. I appreciate it.
Off topic, but here’s an alert for BETSY:
Rank will be running in the Los Alamitos Futurity Saturday, along with Breeders’ Cup Juvenile heavyweights Gaming and Getaway Car. Hot topic Journalism is entered too. Should be a good race.
Hey Ms!
If you got that from the DRF – yes, Rank is running. But, Steve Anderson didn’t do much research – Journalism isn’t even nominated. And, while the BB horses might run, it sounded like speculation
If Doug thinks his colt is good enough to compete, and he’s not looking for him to be evtn money in an MSW, then it’s all good
Rank is a true router, and he’s thriving – so why not?
Oh, and thanks!!
I think Rank has a big look, as a maiden in here….it’s a long stretch, so WAIT! Don’t send him, let him take them where he wants, there’s plenty of room in that homestretch, if he’s good enough!..
Matt, I think they sent him last out to prevent the BB horse from getting away – unfortunately a huge long shot also engaged
It’s frustrating when jockeys let a horse cruise in on an easy lead…but I would imagine that Rank will sit around 3-4 lengths off the pace
So excited!
Hi Betsy – I love your passion for Rank. That’s what horse racing is all about. I’m equally excited to see Journalism’s next race. Possibly an Allow. race before he hits the KY Derby trail. A good performance by Rank in the Los Al Futurity would flatter Journalism. I’m excited to have gotten 52-1 in KDFW2 on Journalism. IMO he has the pedigree and the talent to be a major player in the KY Derby.
Hey Joe
I think Journalism and Rank’s race was very strong. I do think the race set up for him, but he’s a terrific Derby prospect. Strange thing, J wasn’t even listed on the nominations list
I’m a huge Honor AP fan, and I think. Rank is very talented – a true router
Let’s hope for a good race!
I remember Cigar, I think he was running in a turf race at Hollywood Park, on Derby Day 1993, when I got 31-1 on Sea Hero, in the Oregon pool—Cigar was favored that day and he got beat….must have been in another barn cuz Cigar ran many races out west, before they realized what they had, on dirt! A true ten furlong monster, for the Mottster! When he came west for the Hollywood Gold Cup he dominated, late! I was in Oregon when he got beat at Del Mar, and they had it live, on the radio—Jerry Bailey was terrible, after the race…blaming Corey Nakatani for rising Dramatic Gold the same way he always ran. ..compared to what Bailey did on Eddington…a closer pressing Smarty Jones into defeat, in the Belmont—a horse he tried to poach, from Stewart Elliot before The Derby! But what a tale, Steve! You brought me into that cockpit! Had me jumping up and down, with you and Ray Paulick! As I “walked out” of Madison Square Garden I was looking thru glossy eyes, I thank you for this!….
What a treat, Steve, to read about YOUR travels and experiences during Cigar’s last campaign. I felt like I was right on the jet with you, Bill and Jerry, the Paulsons, and of course, Oliver. Cigar was such a celebratory horse, and he knew he was special. I’ve probably told this story on this blog before, but in 1996 I was living in Boston. My husband, a friend who rides show horses, and I went to Suffolk Downs to watch him win the Mass Cap with ease. Afterwards, fans were allowed to gather around the horse in the winner’s circle after the ceremony, so we three went down. Cigar had such a presence. My husband, not particularly a fan of horse racing, observed that the horse not only enjoyed the adulation, he knew he deserved it.
THanks for sharing.
What a ride Cigar gave you, Steve! (Better than the camel ride!). I was a big Cigar fan. Amazing what Mott got out of him after taking him off the turf. I saw Cigar at the Kentucky Horse Park in 2000. He still had the look of a champion. The incomparable Cigar. Thanks for sharing your insider experiences.
Mott was brilliant with Cigar!
Steve thanks for sharing the wonderful story about Cigar and his illustrious team. What marvelous memories that must have been. A horse could not have classier connections than the Paulsons and Bill Mott and company.
I wonder if you could repost the story (you wrote) of the previous year’s champion, Holy Bull. The stories and legends of Cigar and Holy Bull are linked as Holy Bull was injured and pulled up in the Donn Handicap. That is where the legend of the great Cigar was born.
There’s a 20-point Derby prep race coming up tomorrow at the Kawasaki racecourse in Japan. It’s the Zen Nippon Nisai Yushan Stakes, at 1600 meters (about a mile) over the dirt track. Soldier Field, by Le Vent Se Leve, out of a Ammirare mare, appears to be the one to beat. He’s either won or placed in seven career starts (7: 4-3-0) so he certainly has made a good accounting of himself so far. His sire, Le Vent Se Leve, won this race in 2017, and went on to win several graded races in Japan. There were plans to ship him here for the 2018 Kentucky Derby, but an injury cancelled those plans.
Soldier Field is in bred to the great sire, Sunday Silence for what that’s worth.
If he wins referenced race, will his connections start making plans for a shot at the Derby? Stay tuned.
Soldier Field finished a close 3rd, 1 1/2 lengths behind the winner, Myriad Love. From my perspective, Soldier Field needs more distance to show his true potential.
Watching the video replay of the race, the horse than impressed me the most was the #2 horse, Jugemoon, who was flying late on the far outside, to finish 5th.
The Hyacinth (30 Derby points) at about one mile, is coming up in February, and the 40-point Fukuryu at about 1 1/8 miles, is scheduled for March 22nd.
The winner of the Fukuryu should identify Japan’s best colt to ship over for the 2025 Kentucky Derby.
In this year’s Derby, Forever Young was right there at the finish with Mystic Dan and Sierra Leone. Suffice to say, a colt from Japan will eventually win the Derby.
Could the 2025 KD be the year? We’ll see.
Steve, maybe it is a getting older thing (for me at least) but I enjoy reading about these legends of the past like Cigar more than the horses today. So thank you for another road trip down memory lane. It is always a joy.
I thought the name Madeleine (Paulson) Pickens sounded familiar other than in reference to Cigar, so I spent a little time this morning reading about her.
She is a philanthropist and advocate for the Wild Mustangs and purchased a total of close to 20,000 acres and started a wild horse refuge in Nevada and was the founder of the Saving America’s Mustangs. In addition she lobbied for the AHSPA (American Horse Slaughter Prevention Act).
I will always regret that I didn’t have TV the years Cigar was racing. I completely missed him! The closest I came to him was seeing his gravestone at the Kentucky Horse Park. Thank you for sharing these memories, Steve, and giving me a sense of him. It was a pleasure to travel back in time with you.
Steve, where has time gone! it’s been 38 years since Cigar and it seems like yesterday in my memory. I took more then a few 5 or 6 hour rides to be a witness to him. You could feel the electricity and anticipation in the air of him! people thought said I was crazy and I just gave them that crazy like a fox smile back at them. I never bet against him and when he lost to Skip Away in the Jockey Club I only pounded the exacta box. That was a good day for I had Same Old Wish (Same Old Wish was born on my birthday, what Kismet) at 35 to 1 and the exacta with Da Hoss which was the 2nd longest photo finish I have ever endured. With that I’m now looking at a framed photo of Cigar on my wall right in front of me. Great piece Steve!~
Cigar, born 1990.
sleep deprivation will do that to you!
Derek, only 28 years, but I concur about time flying! 1996 was the date I started a job that I still hold, even though our little magazine (Old House Journal) has gone through multiple owners. Still have the same wonderful editor, fortunately.
That is interesting. Been purchasing and now following the publication on FB!
For the pedigree afficionados that support this blog. The two greats, Cigar and Secretariat had no inbreeding in their first 5 generation. Their dam likewise had no inbreeding in their first generations.
Curlin, Invasor and Mystik Dan who held on for dear life in the 2024 KD, to name a few more. Have no inbreeding in their first 5 generation and likewise their dams.
Cigar was sired by Place Music a grandson of Northern Dancer and out of a Seattle Slew mare.
Given the greatness of Cigar, the cross between the Norther Dancer sire line and the Seattle Slew broodmare line would be one that breeders would experiment with.
Off the 6 KD winners sired by Northern Dancer line stallions none were with mare sired by a Seattle Slew line stallion.
Two Phills who was sired by Hard Spun a grandson of Norther Dancer and whose dam was sire by a Seattle Slew line stallion went close in 2023. But a colt from the more productive cross (Northern Dancer/Mr. Prospector) mowed him down late.
A colt mentioned two blogs ago has the Norther Dancer/Seattle Slew line cross. That colt is the very promising Sovereignty, who interesting is in the hands of Cigar’s trainer Bill Mott.
Good info! Cigar was a once in a lifetime.
Thankfully, he was in the hands of a patient and capable trainer, like Mott!
Correct! Right trainer at right time.
Hey Counter Point.
I noticed that Sovereignty hasn’t recorded an official work since his impressive win in the Street Sense Stakes (10-27). With no setbacks announced, I would think Mott is just giving Sovereignty a good rest.
I have Sovereignty listed at number 2, on my top 5 Derby prospects, four of which were sired by Into Mischief.
Patch Adams (Into Mischief)
Sovereignty (Into Mischief)
Citizen Bull (Into Mischief)
Praetor (Into Mischief)
Bullard (Gun Runner)
Bottom line, Sovereignty’s dam side is the personification of class and stamina, with the likes of Bernardini, Empire Maker, A.P. Indy, Seatle Slew, Quiet American, Unbridled and Seeking the Gold appearing in his first four generations.
In addition, Sovereignty is a Godolphin homebred which certainly adds to his allure.
In the KD pool 2 sires list, it came as no surprise that Into Mischief closed at 12-1 odds, which was the lowest odds of all the sires listed.
The 2025 Kentucky Derby winner could very well be the 3rd colt sired by Into Mischief to win the Derby. The first two were, Authentic (2020), and Mandaloun (2021) by default.
BTW, there are several similarities between Mandaloun’s pedigree and that of Sovereignty.
Just something to ponder.
Thank you for sharing your experience. Cigar was truely a unbelievable amazing horse. I was fortunate to see him win the Hollywood Gold Cup during his streak. Never seen another horse quite like him since nor will we ever.
Fortunate to visit him many times in Kentucky,as well as exactly two weeks prior to his passing.
Thank you Steve. Tears in my eyes reading about Cigar at Madison Square Garden!